I believe that i have a weird taste when it comes to anime ... and everything really .... so in this post I wanted to tell you guys how i rank animes.
Basically i rank animes on 5 aspects :-
First ill address the story, an anime without a good story is not a good anime no matter how high the other aspects are to me, and i can't give an anime more than 6 out of 10 if the story is not good. Seiken Tsukai no World Break is a good example of that, and don't get me wrong i enjoy watching the anime but can't help but think about how the hell did a normal guy became one of the strongest characters in the anime just by remembering some stuff, i mean seriously just in every episode he remembers some old spell or tactic from his past life making him dominate his enemies, i mean you really don't feel like he deserves his powers. On the other hand some animes have the story as their strong point like Code Geass, which to me doesnt have animations that are excellent and not all or even most of its soundtracks are great, but the anime breaks the rating charts and i would say mainly because of the epic story and the way its tolled.
Characters and character development is as important as the story to me. I prefer having an anime with few characters all of which have their unique personality than to have an anime where there are just too many characters with similar personalities or the generic anime personalities. I have two good examples of this, first is Toradora, there are only four main characters but all have a well written and unique personality. Love hina does have i think seven main characters and much more minor ones and it had lots of fan service which kept otakus watching more and more .. which i happen to be one of .. however this recipe back then was unique and entertaining and so love hina was a great anime, but sadly this recipe is just over used now, just with better drawing/animation and worse story, and its really getting boring.
Animations play a big role in action animes, and good animations improve any other anime in general. Some of the animes that came out recently have like those great animations and art but unfortunately are lacking in other aspects, however for those animes that strike a good balance between nice animations and a great story, make the anime just that much better like Kyoukai no Kanata. Drawing style to me is an important aspect to me, because it is what i look at when i watch an anime, and something like Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko gets a perfect 10 in its style because there is just so much details and its apparent that the artist took their time to perfect their style, again unlike something generic like most ongoing animes or something like Akikan.
Soundtracks are what you listen to all the time in the anime, and they just linger around even after you finish the anime, that is if they are good. A good anime will have great OST but more importantly play them in the right time at the right volume, and some of the animes that stand out in terms of OST are things like Rozen maiden, Arakawa Under the Bridge and Toaru Majutsu no Index.
Finally my personal feeling towards an anime. Hey this is my blog and my reviews, i mean i might give an awesome anime an average rating not because its an average anime or its bad, its just because its not my type of anime. To get the general rating of an anime you should go to myanimelist or animenewsnetwork, however i can't neglect my own feelings towards an anime, how i got connected or didnt, in my review. The main reason why xxxHOLiC is my all time top anime is because im so attached to it personally and i admit that to the rest of people it is not a 10/10 anime.
So now you know how i rate animes .. yah .. bye :p
Basically i rank animes on 5 aspects :-
- The story and how it's told
- Characters and their development throughout the anime
- Drawing and animation
- Soundtracks
- My personal feeling and attachment
First ill address the story, an anime without a good story is not a good anime no matter how high the other aspects are to me, and i can't give an anime more than 6 out of 10 if the story is not good. Seiken Tsukai no World Break is a good example of that, and don't get me wrong i enjoy watching the anime but can't help but think about how the hell did a normal guy became one of the strongest characters in the anime just by remembering some stuff, i mean seriously just in every episode he remembers some old spell or tactic from his past life making him dominate his enemies, i mean you really don't feel like he deserves his powers. On the other hand some animes have the story as their strong point like Code Geass, which to me doesnt have animations that are excellent and not all or even most of its soundtracks are great, but the anime breaks the rating charts and i would say mainly because of the epic story and the way its tolled.
Characters and character development is as important as the story to me. I prefer having an anime with few characters all of which have their unique personality than to have an anime where there are just too many characters with similar personalities or the generic anime personalities. I have two good examples of this, first is Toradora, there are only four main characters but all have a well written and unique personality. Love hina does have i think seven main characters and much more minor ones and it had lots of fan service which kept otakus watching more and more .. which i happen to be one of .. however this recipe back then was unique and entertaining and so love hina was a great anime, but sadly this recipe is just over used now, just with better drawing/animation and worse story, and its really getting boring.
Animations play a big role in action animes, and good animations improve any other anime in general. Some of the animes that came out recently have like those great animations and art but unfortunately are lacking in other aspects, however for those animes that strike a good balance between nice animations and a great story, make the anime just that much better like Kyoukai no Kanata. Drawing style to me is an important aspect to me, because it is what i look at when i watch an anime, and something like Denpa Onna to Seishun Otoko gets a perfect 10 in its style because there is just so much details and its apparent that the artist took their time to perfect their style, again unlike something generic like most ongoing animes or something like Akikan.
Soundtracks are what you listen to all the time in the anime, and they just linger around even after you finish the anime, that is if they are good. A good anime will have great OST but more importantly play them in the right time at the right volume, and some of the animes that stand out in terms of OST are things like Rozen maiden, Arakawa Under the Bridge and Toaru Majutsu no Index.
Finally my personal feeling towards an anime. Hey this is my blog and my reviews, i mean i might give an awesome anime an average rating not because its an average anime or its bad, its just because its not my type of anime. To get the general rating of an anime you should go to myanimelist or animenewsnetwork, however i can't neglect my own feelings towards an anime, how i got connected or didnt, in my review. The main reason why xxxHOLiC is my all time top anime is because im so attached to it personally and i admit that to the rest of people it is not a 10/10 anime.
So now you know how i rate animes .. yah .. bye :p